PanSpanTupperware Pie Container
Which pie container should I choose to store leftovers and carry pies without squishing the crust or toppings?
For a large pie and everyday fridge storage, I’d choose the Tupperware 12-inch Pie Round Keeper: it’s the closest match to a roomy, sealed pie taker. If carrying one-handed is your priority, the Southern Homewares carrier is the pick with a handle. The other two are practical two-packs for standard pies, but none is a sure bet for a tall meringue or a heavy glass dish without checking the fit first.
#1 · Tupperware
Tupperware 12" Pie Round Keeper Cake Taker Aqua Blue
Choose this for large pies and leftovers you want covered securely: it measures 12 inches across, is 2.75 inches deep, and has an airtight, liquid-tight seal. It’s also freezer-safe and dishwasher-safe.
#2 · Southern Homewares
Southern Homewares Pie Carrier with Lid and Handle – 3-in-1 Plastic Dessert Container for Pies, Cakes, Cupcakes, and Muffins
Take this if a handle and flexibility across different desserts matter most. Its 3-in-1 set includes containers for pies, cakes, cupcakes, muffins and deviled eggs, making it the most adaptable option for bringing something to a gathering.
#3 · Mission Gallery
2 Pack Pie Carrier with Airtight Lid - Transport Pie Container, Storage | Plastic Pie Containers Fit Most Pies, Bakery - BPA Free Pie Saver, Keeper with Cover to Keep Pies Fresh, Pie Dish Holder
Pick this two-pack for standard pies when you want a flat, stackable lid and containers that can also go in the microwave for short reheating intervals. It’s sized for pies up to 10 inches across and 2.25 inches high.
#4 · Zilpoo
Zilpoo 2 Pack Plastic Round Food Storage Containers with Lid, 10.5" Covered Pie Keeper, Christmas Cookie, Cupcake Carrier, Cheesecake Holder
Choose this two-pack if you regularly store or transport standard pies, cookies or other baked goods and want two containers on hand. It fits pies up to 10 inches and is freezer-safe, dishwasher-safe and microwave-safe.
Will a deep-dish ceramic pie plate fit inside?
Don’t judge by the pie’s diameter alone: measure the plate across its widest point, including a ruffled rim, and measure from the bottom of the plate to the top of the crust or topping. The Mission Gallery option specifically accommodates a baking dish, but its stated pie limit is 10 inches across and 2.25 inches high. The Tupperware keeper is sized for a large pie, not a guarantee that a wide-rimmed ceramic plate will fit. If you need to carry the pie in its own heavy plate, confirm both measurements before choosing.
Is a handle more important than a tight seal?
For carrying one-handed, choose the Southern Homewares carrier; it’s the pick here with a handle. For sealed storage, choose the Tupperware keeper, which has an airtight, liquid-tight seal. Don’t assume a handle makes a heavy glass or ceramic plate safe to carry: keep the carrier level and support its base when the dish is heavy.
What works for a tall meringue or high-mounded pie?
Compare the pie’s height—including the tallest topping—with the container’s usable space, not its outside dimensions. The Tupperware keeper is 2.75 inches deep, so I wouldn’t choose it for a tall topping unless you’ve checked the clearance. For lemon meringue, chill the pie fully, keep the carrier level, and leave enough room that the lid cannot touch the topping.
Do I need one carrier or a two-pack?
Choose the Southern Homewares carrier if you want a handle and flexibility for different desserts. Choose Mission Gallery or Zilpoo if having two containers is more useful than a handle. Mission is the more clearly defined fit for standard pies and flat, stackable fridge storage; Zilpoo suits standard pies and other everyday baked goods.
How they compare
Which one is yours
Tupperware: You want a roomy keeper for a large pie, with a secure seal for fridge or freezer storage.
Southern Homewares: You want a handled carrier that can serve different kinds of desserts for gatherings.
Mission Gallery: You want two flat-lidded containers for standard pies and compact, stackable storage.
Zilpoo: You want a two-pack for standard pies and a mix of other baked goods.
You will also want
If you bake the pie yourself, a rack for cooling and mitts for handling the hot plate are the useful companions here.
Ultra Cuisine Cooling and Baking Rack Set - Cooling Racks -11.5'' x16.5'' | 100% Stainless Steel, Oven-Safe, Dishwasher-Safe, Heavy Duty Tight-Wire, Set of 2, Half Sheet Pan Cooling Racks, Easy Clean
Cool the pie completely on a rack before putting on the lid, which helps avoid trapped warmth and a softened crust.
GORILLA GRIP Silicone Oven Mitts, 550F Heat Resistant, 12.5x8.3, Black | BPA-Free Cooking Waterproof Safety Gloves, Thick Cotton Lining, Flexible Gripping for Baking, Grilling, Kitchen Potholder Set
Use oven mitts to move the hot pie plate safely from the oven to a cooling rack before packing it for travel.
Questions buyers ask
How do I stop a lemon meringue pie from getting squashed in transit?
Let the pie cool and chill before covering it, then use a carrier with enough clearance that the lid cannot touch the meringue. Keep it level in the car, secured on a flat surface, and avoid stacking anything on top. If the topping is especially tall, check the usable height before choosing a carrier.
Will a ruffled ceramic pie dish fit in a pie keeper?
It depends on the dish’s widest point and height, including the ruffled rim. Measure those against the carrier’s usable interior space; a carrier sized for a pie itself isn’t automatically sized for the dish it was baked in. Mission Gallery is the option here that specifically says it accommodates a baking dish, within its stated pie limits.
Are pie-carrier handles safe for a heavy glass pie plate?
I wouldn’t rely on a handle alone with a heavy glass or ceramic dish. Carry the carrier level and support its base, especially when the pie plate is heavy or fits snugly.
Which option has a locking lid?
The Tupperware’s airtight, liquid-tight seal and Mission Gallery’s snap-on lid are not the same as locking clamps. If locking latches are essential, choose a carrier explicitly designed with them; don’t mistake a tight seal for a lock.
Can I use a pie keeper for leftovers?
Yes. Let the pie cool fully before covering it so trapped heat and condensation don’t soften the crust. Choose a keeper sized to the pie, and avoid stacking anything on top.
What should I look for if I want inserts or easier pie removal?
For a multi-use carrier, check which containers or trays are actually included: the Southern Homewares 3-in-1 set covers pies, cupcakes and deviled eggs. For easier pie removal, look for a lift-out tray or a low rim with room to get your fingers under the plate; don’t assume a pie carrier includes a lifter or insert.