PanSpanTeflon Baking Pan
Which of these nonstick baking pans is the right fit for what I cook?
For a dependable all-rounder, I’d choose the Farberware 9×13: it’s built for even heating, resists warping and is rated for a higher oven temperature than the other rectangular options. The GoodCook is the one to choose if you want a scratch-resistant coating that can handle metal utensils, while the square pans suit brownies and smaller cakes. One important distinction: these are deep baking pans, not flat sheet pans for spreading out cookies or vegetables.
Teflon isn’t among these picks. The Farberware comes closest to what you were after: a familiar 9×13 nonstick baking pan, with heavy-duty construction, an even-heating design and a stated 450°F oven limit.
#1 · Farberware
Farberware Nonstick Bakeware 9-Inch x 13-Inch Rectangular Cake Pan, Gray | Bake brownies and casseroles, 13x9 baking pan for even heating, non stick baking pans, dishwasher safe, 450F safe
Choose this 9×13 pan for brownies, casseroles and everyday baking when sturdy construction and even heating matter most. It’s also the strongest fit here if you want the highest stated oven-temperature limit among the rectangular pans.
#2 · GoodCook
Good Cook Everyday Bake & Roast Pan with Scratch-Resistant Metal-Utensil Safe Nonstick, 13 x 9-Inch, Gray
This is the pick if you want to serve from the pan with a metal spatula: its scratch-resistant coating is described as safe for metal utensils. Its 9×13 shape also covers cakes, roasted vegetables and casseroles.
#3 · Amazon Basics
Amazon Basics Nonstick Rectangle Baking Pan, 9 x 13 in., Perfect for Cakes, Dishwasher and Oven-Safe
Choose this straightforward 9×13 option for everyday cakes and brownies, especially if dishwasher cleanup is a priority. For the coating’s best performance, hand-wash it even though it is dishwasher-safe.
#4 · OXO
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Ceramic Coated 9-Inch Square Cake Pan | Storm Blue, Baking Essentials, Brownies, Cakes, Dishwasher Safe, Secure Grip, Easy Turnout, High Walls for Even Browning
This square pan is for neat, uniform cake layers and brownies when a 9×13 pan would be more space than you need. Its ceramic coating, rounded interior corners and expanded rim handles make it a considered choice for regular baking.
#5 · Wilton
Wilton Platinum Non-Stick Square Pan, Made Without PFAS, 9 x 9 in | DURALAST Silicone Infused Double Coating, 5X More Durable with Anti-Warping Technology, Perfect for Brownies & Square Cakes
Pick this 9-inch square pan for brownies or small cakes if you want a square pan with a stated 450°F oven limit and an easy-release coating. It is also a good fit when anti-warping design and extended handles are priorities.
Do you need a flat sheet pan or a deep baking pan?
For brownies, casseroles and cake mixes, take the Farberware or GoodCook 9×13. These have the depth for batters and saucy dishes, but they are not flat rimmed cookie sheets or half-sheet pans. For vegetables that need room to brown, spread them out on a proper sheet pan instead; crowding them in a deep pan tends to trap steam.
Which pan is better for high heat and resisting warping?
The Farberware is my pick for high-heat flexibility among the rectangular pans: it’s described as heavy-duty, warp-resistant and oven-safe to 450°F. The GoodCook is another sturdy-feeling option on paper, with heavy-gauge steel designed to resist warping, and it adds metal-utensil-safe coating. The Amazon Basics pan has carbon-steel construction but a lower stated oven limit, so I’d reserve it for routine baking rather than choosing it for the hottest roasting.
How much should dishwasher use and utensil choice affect you?
The Farberware and Amazon Basics are both dishwasher-safe, but each recommends hand-washing for best coating performance. OXO and Wilton also state that their square pans are dishwasher-safe; gentle hand-washing is still the kinder routine for coated bakeware. If you often cut or serve directly in the pan with a metal spatula, choose the GoodCook rather than assuming every nonstick coating can take the same treatment.
When is a square pan the better buy?
Choose the OXO or Wilton when your recipes call for a 9-inch square pan, or when you prefer smaller batches of brownies and cakes. The OXO’s light interior is designed for even browning and its rounded corners are easier to clean. The Wilton suits higher-heat baking, with a stated 450°F oven limit and an anti-warping design.
How they compare
Which one is yours
Farberware: You want the most versatile 9×13 for cakes, brownies and casseroles, with a high stated oven limit and warp-resistant construction.
GoodCook: You want a 9×13 pan whose coating is designed to tolerate metal utensils.
Amazon Basics: You want a simple 9×13 for everyday baking and value the option of dishwasher cleanup.
OXO: You bake square cakes or brownies and value its ceramic coating, easy-clean interior corners and rim handles.
Wilton: You want a 9-inch square pan with a stated 450°F oven limit and an anti-warping design.
You will also want
A soft cleaning tool and non-scratch utensils help protect coated surfaces, while good grip and a heat-safe landing spot make hot pans easier to manage.
KitchenAid Ribbed Soft Silicone Pot Holder 2-Pack Set, Blue Willow, 7"x9"
Use these pot holders to get a secure grip when moving a hot pan from oven to counter.
Zulay Kitchen 5 Piece Silicone Utensil Set | Non-Stick Silicone Cooking Utensils Set with Acacia Wood Handles - 464°F Heat Resistance Kitchen Utensils Set - Gray
Silicone utensils are a good everyday choice for releasing and serving food without scraping most nonstick coatings.
Kodreat 4 Pack Silicone Trivets for Hot Dishes | Heat-Resistant Non-Slip Hot Pads for Kitchen Countertops and Tables, Food-Grade Thick Silicone Mats (7.1x7.1in)
Set a hot baking pan on a trivet to protect the counter or table after it comes out of the oven.
HOMEXCEL All-Purpose Sponge Pads 12PK, Non-Scratch Dish Sponges for Kitchen | Reusable Wire Dishwashing Rag, All-Purpose Scrub for Non-Stick Cookware/Dishes/Countertops/Bathroom/Household, Silver
Non-scratch sponges make it easier to clean coated bakeware without reaching for an abrasive scrubber.
Premium Kitchen Towels 6 Pack 100% Cotton, 20"x28" Dish Towels - Grey | Large Flat & Terry Kitchen Linen Set with Hanging Loops, Highly Absorbent for Washing and Drying Dishes
Keep a kitchen towel nearby for drying a hand-washed pan or wiping up drips around the oven.
BOYAN Pot and Pan Protectors for Stacking, 12pcs & 3 Sizes, Separator Pads | Felt Pan Pot Dividers Protect Cookware, Glassware, Bowls, Dishes and Bakeware From Scratches and Chipping in Cabinet Storage
Pan protectors help prevent scratches if you stack bakeware in a cupboard.
Questions buyers ask
Are any of these pans a good substitute for a nonstick baking sheet?
They’re baking pans, not flat rimmed sheet pans. The 9×13 options work well for brownies, cakes and casseroles, but vegetables and cookies usually brown better when spread across a larger, shallower sheet pan.
Can you put nonstick baking pans in the dishwasher?
Farberware, Amazon Basics, OXO and Wilton state that their pans are dishwasher-safe. Farberware and Amazon Basics also recommend hand-washing for best performance; gentle hand-washing is a sensible way to help any coated pan last.
How do I help keep a nonstick coating from peeling or scratching?
Avoid abrasive scrubbers, sharp-edged tools and cutting food in the pan, and wash with a soft sponge and mild soap. The GoodCook is the exception if you specifically need metal-utensil use; for the other pans, use silicone or wooden tools.
Is ceramic-coated bakeware safe around pet birds?
A ceramic coating by itself is not a bird-safety guarantee. Birds are unusually sensitive to airborne fumes, so if a pet bird shares your home, favor uncoated bakeware and keep coated pans well away from the bird’s airspace, especially during high-heat cooking.
Which pan should I choose for roasting vegetables?
For a small amount, a 9×13 pan can roast vegetables; don’t crowd them if you want browning rather than steaming. For regular sheet-pan dinners, none of these is a flat sheet pan, so choose a shallow rimmed pan instead.
Is the Farberware pan made without PFAS?
Farberware says it is responsibly made without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium, and that those substances are not intentionally added to the interior coating. If avoiding those substances is a priority, this is the clearest match among these picks.