PanSpanEkco Pans
Which of these pans is the best durable replacement for an old-fashioned 9×13 baking pan?
For a reusable 9×13 workhorse, I’d choose the USA Pan: it’s made from aluminized steel, has a corrugated surface, and releases baked goods with a nonstick coating. Good Cook is my practical alternative if metal-utensil-safe coating and straightforward roasting matter most; Farberware is appealing if dishwasher-safe cleanup is a priority. None of the reusable pans here is uncoated, so if avoiding a coating is your main requirement, these picks don’t quite match it.
Ekco isn’t among the available picks. For a reusable, familiar-size 9×13 pan, Good Cook comes closest, with durable steel, metal-utensil-safe nonstick and straightforward baking and roasting use.
#1 · USA Pan
USA Pan Bakeware Nonstick Rectangular Cake Pan, 9 x 13-inch | Cake pans, rectangular cake pans, 9 x 13-inch size, nonstick bakeware, baking pan for cakes, cake baking
Choose this for a durable, familiar-size 9×13 pan for cakes, casseroles and holiday baking. Its aluminized steel construction and corrugated surface make it the strongest all-around choice here, though it does have a nonstick coating.
#2 · GoodCook
Good Cook Everyday Bake & Roast Pan with Scratch-Resistant Metal-Utensil Safe Nonstick, 13 x 9-Inch, Gray
Take this if you want a no-frills 13×9 steel pan for everyday baking and roasting. Its coating is described as safe for metal utensils, a useful advantage when you like to serve straight from the pan.
#3 · Farberware
Farberware Nonstick Bakeware 9-Inch x 13-Inch Rectangular Cake Pan, Gray | Bake brownies and casseroles, 13x9 baking pan for even heating, non stick baking pans, dishwasher safe, 450F safe
Pick this for a 9×13 pan that can go in the dishwasher and is oven safe to 450°F. Hand washing is recommended to keep its nonstick finish performing well over time.
#4 · Ekau
Ekau Essential Bake and Roast Pan, Black
Choose this when you want a carbon-steel-core bake-and-roast pan with nonstick release and a grippy rim design. It’s the less obvious choice if matching a precise 9×13 recipe footprint is essential.
#5 · EKACO
EKACO 9x13 Aluminum Foil Pans with Lids, 10 Pack 120 Micron Heavy Duty Disposable Trays, Thickened Half Size Tin Foil Baking Pans for Roasting, Cooking, Meal Prep, Baking
These foil pans are for meal prep, gatherings and cooking that you’d rather not clean up afterward. The pack includes lids, but for easier handling when loaded, set a foil pan on a sturdy baking sheet before filling or moving it.
Do you want a reusable pan or one you can toss?
For regular family recipes, choose the USA Pan or Good Cook: both are reusable metal pans in the familiar 9×13 range. The USA Pan is my first choice for a lasting baking staple; Good Cook is the simpler option if you want to use metal utensils. Pick the EKACO foil pans for potlucks, batch cooking or a meal where avoiding the washing-up matters more than keeping the pan.
Is avoiding a nonstick coating a must?
None of the reusable choices here is an uncoated pan: USA Pan, Good Cook, Farberware and Ekau all have nonstick coatings. If you’re comfortable with a coating, the USA Pan is my durability-minded pick, while Good Cook gives you the specific benefit of a metal-utensil-safe surface. For a longer-lasting finish, use silicone or wooden tools and wash gently rather than scrubbing hard.
Which pan is easiest to live with after baking?
For the dishwasher, Farberware is the clear choice, though hand washing is recommended for best performance. Good Cook’s metal-utensil-safe coating is convenient for cutting or serving in the pan, but gentle cleaning is still sensible for any coated bakeware. If cleanup is the main problem, the EKACO foil pans sidestep it altogether.
Does the pan need to match a familiar recipe size?
For a clearly identified 9×13 pan, take the USA Pan or Farberware; Good Cook is also identified as 13×9. That familiar footprint is useful for classic cake, brownie and casserole recipes. Choose Ekau when you want its carbon-steel-core bake-and-roast design but aren’t relying on an exact 9×13 fit.
How they compare
Which one is yours
USA Pan: You want the best all-around reusable 9×13 pan for cakes, casseroles and dependable everyday baking, and are fine with a nonstick coating.
GoodCook: You want a practical steel 13×9 pan whose coating is safe for metal utensils.
Farberware: Dishwasher-safe cleanup and a stated 450°F oven limit are your deciding factors.
Ekau: You want a carbon-steel-core pan for baking and roasting and don’t need a confirmed 9×13 recipe fit.
EKACO: You need lidded disposable trays for meal prep, gatherings or easy cleanup.
You will also want
A couple of simple tools make coated bakeware easier to handle and care for: protect the finish while serving, and give hot pans a safe landing spot.
Umite Chef Kitchen Cooking Utensils Set, 33 pcs Non-Stick Silicone Cooking Kitchen Spatula Set with Holder, Wooden Handle Silicone Kitchen Gadgets Utensil Set (Black)
Silicone utensils help you lift and serve food without scraping the nonstick coatings.
Scotch-Brite Zero Scratch Scrub Sponge, 6 Pack | Kitchen Sponges for Cleaning Home, Bathroom, Effective + Gentle Dish Scrubber, Safe on Nonstick surfaces
These zero-scratch sponges are a sensible choice for cleaning coated pans without reaching for an abrasive scrubber.
4 Pcs Oven Mitts and Pot Holders,High Heat 500°F Resistant Glove Potholder with Thick Cotton,Silicone Non-Slip Surface Long Kitchen Oven Glove for Cooking Baking Grilling(Grey)
Oven mitts make it easier to grip and carry hot bakeware safely.
Silicone Trivets for Hot Pots and Pans - 2 Heat Resistant Pot Holders Silicone Trivet Mat Multipurpose Counter Pads (Black)
A heat-resistant trivet gives a hot pan a place to rest without putting it directly on the counter.
Questions buyers ask
Are any of these reusable pans uncoated?
None in this selection. When shopping elsewhere, look for product wording that explicitly identifies a bare-metal cooking surface; “metal” alone doesn’t establish that it is uncoated.
Which pan is best for even baking?
I’d start with the USA Pan: it’s made from aluminized steel, which combines steel strength with aluminum heat conductivity, and its corrugated surface is designed to promote airflow. Avoid darkening or damaging the coating, and use the pan according to the recipe rather than assuming every oven bakes alike.
How can I help a nonstick baking pan last?
Let the pan cool before washing, and avoid stacking it against other cookware without a protector. Farberware is dishwasher safe, but hand washing is recommended for best performance.
Can I use the foil pans for roasting or meal prep?
Yes. The EKACO trays are intended for roasting, cooking, baking, meal prep and food storage, and come with lids.
Can I put these pans in the microwave?
Do not put the EKACO foil pans in a microwave; they are not recommended for microwave use. For the reusable pans, use an appliance only when the pan’s instructions allow it.